Sometimes a new recipe comes about simply because I cannot bear to throw away something good. That is how these pears in plum pickling liquid came into being.
I recently made sweet-and-sour pickled plums. The plums went into jars, leaving me with quite a lot of pickling liquid: around three 700 ml jars, or roughly 2.1 litres. For this pear recipe, I measure out approximately 1.2–1.5 litres.
I could have poured it away, but after being poured over the plums three times, it had developed a lovely, subtle plum flavour. With 1.2 kg of pears still waiting in the kitchen, the answer seemed obvious.
I made pickled pears.
These are different from my grandmother’s traditional pickled pears. Here I use liquid that has already taken on the flavour of plums. I see this recipe as a small kitchen experiment and a way to make use of something that might otherwise have gone down the sink.
What Can You Do with Leftover Plum Pickling Liquid?
That was the first question I asked myself.
My plum pickling liquid contained water, vinegar, sugar, cloves and allspice. While making the pickled plums, however, I had heated it several times and it had been in contact with the fruit. I did not want simply to add the pears and leave it at that.
I brought the liquid back to the boil and gave it a little extra flavour. I added fresh distilled vinegar with 10% acidity, a few cloves and some allspice berries. If the liquid needs more sweetness, you can add a little sugar; I did not. I did not add any water either, as I wanted to retain its distinct sweet-and-sour character.
How Are These Different from Ordinary Pickled Pears?
The main difference is the pickling liquid.
For the traditional recipe, I make it specifically for the pears. Here, the liquid has already been in contact with plums, which have released some of their juice and aroma into it.
If you are looking for a traditional preserve, see my grandmother’s pickled pear recipe.
I make today’s pears differently. I do not process the jars in a water bath, and I keep them in the fridge for no more than two weeks. For me, this is primarily a way to use the aromatic liquid left over from making another preserve.
Which Pears Should You Choose?
I use Conference pears, choosing fruit that is ripe but still firm. Soft pears can quickly lose their texture in hot liquid, and I wanted mine to remain firm enough to slice and serve alongside a meal.
I peel the pears, cut them in half and remove the cores. Larger pears can be quartered. If preparation takes a little longer, put the peeled pears in cold water with a little lemon juice to stop them browning.
Pears in Plum Pickling Liquid
3-4
jars25
minutesPears in an aromatic sweet-and-sour liquid left over from making pickled plums. A simple way to use the remaining liquid rather than pour it away.
Ingredients
1.2 kg firm pears
approximately 1.2–1.5 litres of liquid left over from making pickled plums
approximately 100–150 ml distilled vinegar with 10% acidity
70–100 g sugar, only if the liquid needs sweetening
4–5 cloves
3 allspice berries
optional: lemon juice for the water used to hold the peeled pears
Method
Prepare the pears. Wash thoroughly, peel, halve or quarter, and remove the cores.

Prepare the jars. Wash and sterilise the jars and lids thoroughly.
Refresh the plum pickling liquid. Measure out around 1.2–1.5 litres and pour it into a saucepan. Add the vinegar, cloves and allspice.
Check the flavour. My liquid was already sweet from the plums, so I add sugar only if it needs it. If necessary, add around 70–100 g.
Simmer the pears in the liquid. Bring the spiced pickling liquid to the boil. Add the prepared pears and simmer gently for a dozen or so minutes, checking their texture. They should soften slightly while still holding their shape.

Transfer the pears to jars. Carefully lift the hot, lightly cooked pears out of the saucepan and arrange them in clean, scalded jars without pressing them in too tightly.

Add the liquid. Pour the hot plum pickling liquid into the jars, making sure it covers the pears.

Close the jars. Wipe the rims, screw the lids on securely and leave to cool completely.

Refrigerate. I do not process these jars in a water bath. Once cool, I keep them in the fridge and eat the pears within a maximum of two weeks.
Important
This recipe is a way to reuse plum pickling liquid, not a recipe for preserves to store in the pantry for months.
Because the liquid has already been in contact with fruit and heated several times, I do not know its final acidity. For that reason, I do not store the finished pears at room temperature.
Once the jars have cooled completely, I put them in the fridge and use them within no more than two weeks.
Do the Jars Need Water-Bath Processing?
For this recipe, I do not process the filled jars in a water bath. First, I bring the spiced pickling liquid to the boil, add the pears and simmer them gently for a dozen or so minutes. I check their texture so they do not become too soft.
I then transfer the hot pears to clean, scalded jars and cover them with the same hot liquid from the saucepan. I close the lids and refrigerate the jars once they have cooled. I keep them refrigerated at all times and use them within a maximum of two weeks.
These pears are intended for short-term use. Adding vinegar and pouring hot liquid over the fruit does not make the jars suitable for several months of pantry storage.
What Do Pears in Plum Pickling Liquid Taste Like?
Even before adding the pears, the liquid tasted more interesting than a simple mixture of vinegar, water and sugar. Repeated contact with the plums had given it a fruity character.
That was precisely what I wanted.
I do not want the pears to taste only of vinegar and cloves. They should still taste like pears, with a subtle plum note in the background.
Now comes the hardest part: waiting a few days for the pears to take on the flavour of the liquid.
What Can You Serve with These Pears?
I would serve these pears mainly with savoury dishes: roast meat, pâté, cold cuts or a cheeseboard. Their sweet-and-sour flavour provides a welcome balance to richer foods.
They could also make an interesting addition to a cold platter.
Before thinking up more ways to serve them, though, I will leave them in the fridge to develop their flavour.
From Pickled Plums to a New Recipe
What I like most is that I never planned to make another recipe. First came my grandmother’s traditional pickled pears, then sweet-and-sour pickled plums. The plums left me with some lovely liquid.
I hate throwing away something that can still be put to good use. With another 1.2 kg of pears sitting nearby, I did not have to think for long. One plum recipe led to another: pears in plum pickling liquid.
All that remains is to open the first jar in a few days and find out how much plum flavour the pears have absorbed. The liquid will always vary a little, depending on the plums you use, so the final flavour is not entirely predictable. A previous batch had a pronounced plum flavour. How will this one turn out? We shall see.




